27
32
- Marouane Fellaini: Not consistent enough and it was simply another panic buy.
- Juan Mata: A good buy, continues to be an excellent senior figure on the team.
- Vanja Milinkovic-Savic: Who?
- Radamel Falcao: Good player but struggled majorly in the Premier League.
- Daley Blind: Poor management and recurrent injuries led to his exit.
- Marcos Rojo: Poor signing, failed to do well on Estudiantes loan. Future currently in limbo.
- Ander Herrera: Solid professional but unfairly treated. Has exited Man United.
- Luke Shaw: Developed well over the years but first-team role in doubt after Alex Telles' arrival.
- Angel Di Maria: Let's not even go there.
- Sergio Romero: Reliable No.2 goalkeeper, who has saved us on numerous occasions. Again, poorly managed by the club and is now looking for a way out.
- Bastian Schweinsteiger: Came in as a World Cup winner but struggled at United.
- Matteo Darmian: Poor signing and simply no other way to put it.
- Memphis Depay: A talented player but arguably joined us at the wrong time. Left the club after failing to nail a regular role.
- Morgan Schneiderlin: Yet another poor signing who could not do much for us.
- Anthony Martial: Blossoming into a success and his 17 league goals from last season are a testament to that.
- Zlatan Ibrahimovic: Possibly the most exciting signing since Sir Alex left.
- Eric Bailly: A powerful defender but way too injury-prone. Still is a first-team member.
- Henrikh Mkhitaryan: A bad flop.
- Paul Pogba: Aside from his obsession with all things Real Madrid, he's arguably our most skilled player right now.
- Alexis Sanchez: We paid through our nose for one piano video which wasn't even that good.
- Victor Lindelof: Far too inconsistent and error-prone to be termed a successful buy.
- Nemanja Matic: A true-blue Serbian warrior whose influence cannot be explained in words.
- Romelu Lukaku: Okayish signing but his first touch continues to give us nightmares.
- Lee Grant: Why did we even sign him?
- Diogo Dalot: Decent potential but is hardly getting chances at United.
- Fred: Many wrote him off at first but he's fought hard to become an important first-team player.
- Odion Ighalo: The decision to extend his loan was the right one but he's hardly played for us since then.
- Dan James: The lad is all pace and that's about it.
- Aaron Wan-Bissaka: Defensive beast but very poor while contributing to the attack.
- Bruno Fernandes: Easily, the best out of the lot.
- Harry Maguire: Definitely a good player but has lost his rhythm after the Greece debacle.
- Donny van de Beek: Promising midfielder and great talent but did we really need to sign him now? The jury is still out on that one.
- Amad Diallo: Again, promising player for the future but doesn't solve any of our immediate concerns.
- Alex Telles: A much-needed upgrade at left-back.
- Facundo Pellistri: Ample potential and skills but again, not the best solution for our problems right now.
- Edinson Cavani: A loan or a one-year deal would've been ideal but all will be forgiven if he's able to hit top form.
What do you think of each signing, Reds?
27
32